Banks grapple with GAR objectives
Banks grapple with GAR objectives
Tue 13 Sep 2022
In force since 1 January 2022, the European Union’s Taxonomy regulation aims to support the market for green finance. More specifically, greater transparency in the market will help prevent greenwashing by providing information to investors about the environmental performance of assets and economic activities of financial and non-financial information.
For the banking sector, the target is to measure the share of financing allocated to sustainable economic activities by publishing a Green Asset Ratio (GAR). However, in a recent analysis* of the first GARs issued by the European Union’s 11 leading banks, the absence of information means banks have had no choice but to estimate a company’s level of green finance. These estimates have been taken into account in the ratio published mainly on a voluntary basis by the banks reviewed.
Such voluntary ratios reflect the broadening of the scope of eligible assets by including the financing of companies identified as subject to the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD) or by having an EU economic activity classification through a NACE code listed in the delegated act on climate targets.
Areas of interpretation remain
The methodology for calculating the GAR is governed by Article 8 of the Taxonomy regulation. Despite the additions made by the European Commission’s FAQ of 2 February 2022, some areas of interpretation remain. For example, in terms of the determination of covered assets, there were varying levels of detail in the information published, with 27 % of the banks in the panel not clearly indicating the proportion of exposures covered by the ratio in percentage terms. In comparison, 9 % do not provide detailed information on items excluded from the assets covered. In terms of exclusions applied, 73% of the banks in the panel provide detailed information on items such as derivatives, interbank demand loans or non-NFRD exposures.
In applying eligibility criteria, 91% of banks in the panel provide details on the nature and scope of collateralised real estate loans, while 55% provide similar information on the work loans considered eligible and 64% on the financing of vehicles deemed eligible.
There was also heterogeneity in the eligibility criteria applied. For example, some banks considered the loans to individuals eligible. Others, in the strict application of the text, considered them ineligible because they were granted before January 1, 2022. In addition, some banks considered loans to local authorities ineligible whereas others analysed the eligibility criterion according to the nature of these loans, for example the financing of social housing. Most banks included in eligible assets loans to households, guaranteed by a home loan or a mortgage. More rarely included were loans for home improvement or renovation due to a more complex audit trail.
The challenge for banks in the coming years will be to access relevant information on the eligibility and then the alignment of their financing.
Despite the strengthening of publication obligations through the upcoming application of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) to replace the NFRD, it will nevertheless remain necessary for banks to adapt their information systems to produce reliable information efficiently and to improve the identification of so-called “earmarked” financing whose purpose is known precisely. Finally, the transformation of customer paths to produce reliable and efficient information and organise the collection of new documents needed for taxonomy alignment analysis, such as an Energy Performance Declaration when financing real estate, will be essential.
*For more information, please refer to Les cahiers sectoriels de la taxonomie #1 : Secteur Banque (available in French).
Want to get notified when new blog posts are published?Subscribe
Injecting noise into the discussion
Michael Lennard, Chief of International Tax Cooperation and Trade in the Financing for Sustainable Development Office (FfDO) of the United Nations, examines the role of tax toolkits for developing countries from a personal perspective. The Platform for Collaboration on Tax (PCT) involving the UN, OECD, IMF and the World Bank, is certainly a good example […]
Building a more inclusive tax model
Michael Lennard, Chief of International Tax Cooperation and Trade in the Financing for Sustainable Development Office (FSDO) of the United Nations, discusses, from a personal perspective, a range of key issues on the UN’s approach to transfer pricing. In 2019 the United Nations Tax Committee issued draft guidance on financial transactions. It was finalized in […]
Green taxonomy trends facing the real estate sector
The European Union (EU) has taken the first step in directing capital investments toward so-called sustainable activities with the introduction of the Green Taxonomy on 1 January 2022. For the real estate sector, the objective is to measure the share of eligible activities contributing to the first two climate objectives – the mitigation of climate […]
Reliable information key to the insurance sector’s ability to apply Green Taxonomy
The objective of the European Union’s Taxonomy regulation, in force since 1 January 2022, is twofold for the insurance and reinsurance sector. First, to measure the share of investments devoted to financing economic activities eligible for the taxonomy, known as the Investment Ratio. Second, to measure the share of gross premiums written in eligible non-life […]
The Fed shares instructions on its first pilot climate scenario analysis exercise
The Federal Reserve Board (Fed) has shared instructions on its pilot climate scenario analysis exercise (CSA). Six of the largest U.S. banks, i.e., Bank of America, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, and Wells Fargo are participating in the exercise and are requested to submit their results along with documentation by July 31, 2023. […]
Climate change: the Bank of England’s commitments
In 2018, the Bank of England (the “BoE”) set up a project called “Future of Finance” aimed at anticipating the upcoming changes in financial services for the next decade, and the impact of these changes for market participants, customers and regulators. This research was led by Huw van Steenis, Senior Adviser to the Governor, and […]
A Tax Playbook for the Digitalised Economy (Part 2)
In a series of articles aimed at promoting debate on the evolution of international tax regimes, Michael Lennard, Chief of International Tax Cooperation and Trade in the Financing for Sustainable Development Office (FSDO) of the United Nations, discusses the tax-related challenges governments, professionals and practitioners face. Following on from the first article on this topic, […]
A Tax Playbook for the Digitalised Economy (Part 1)
In a series of articles aimed at promoting debate on the evolution of international tax regimes, Michael Lennard, Chief of International Tax Cooperation and Trade in the Financing for Development Office (FfDO) of the United Nations, discusses the tax-related challenges governments, professionals and practitioners face. In the first of this two-part article, Mr Lennard expresses […]
Addressing the challenges of the new sustainable finance regulations
As the world gears up for the transition to net-zero, the European Union is setting ambitious targets with respect to its own environmental footprint. For instance, by 2030 the EU is looking to reduce European greenhouse gas emissions by at least 55% compared to 1990 levels; increase the share of renewables within Europe’s total energy […]
How banks can demonstrate responsible banking during the pandemic
What is the purpose of a bank? Does it have a responsibility to society at large, over and above its duties to its shareholders, customers and employees? The purpose of banks – to make a profit or be socially useful? What is the purpose of a bank? Does it have a responsibility to society at […]
How will COVID-19 affect the financial regulatory response to climate change?
At first glance, regulatory authorities appear to have deprioritised the issue of climate change. However, a closer look would suggest otherwise and climate change in reality remains a key long-term priority of national and European regulators. In some areas, regulatory action on climate change has been delayed Central banks around the world have taken steps […]
A looming climate crisis?
Persistant negative interest rates, the inherent risk of a trade war between China and the United States, fears of a recession… all worrying signs of an imminent new crisis. However, the real question is not if but when the next crisis will hit. More than ten years after the financial and sovereign debt crisis, it […]
BEAT Could Eat Into Income Tax Savings
Tax legislation generally includes promises to simplify the process of computing taxes. But in the process of transforming legislation into law, those good intentions often are overshadowed by new complexities. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 is no exception, especially for U.S. multinational corporations. Although most corporations herald their much lower 21% tax […]
Climate change: a threat to the stability of the financial services
With rising global temperatures comes an ever-growing pressure on the financial services sector to respond and prepare for the far-reaching effects of climate change. The impacts upon the sector are already being felt – extreme weather events are creating significant losses for insurers and credit risks for banks, and pressures on businesses to demonstrate sustainable […]
How the insurance sector is meeting ESG challenges
This article is part of the series covering the impact of sustainable finance on the insurance sector. Read further:Part 1: Assessing the impact of sustainable finance on insurance entitiesPart 3: Developing a toolkit for responsible investment decisions When taking environmental, social, and long-term asset portfolio issues into consideration, insurance companies must assess the specific risks […]
FATCA and the Common Reporting Standard Applied by Life Insurers – a Few Practical Considerations
Within the insurance industry, automatic exchange of information under Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) and the Common Reporting Standard (CRS) is mainly relevant to life insurers, since non-life insurance and reinsurance activities generally do not give rise to classification and reporting obligations under these regulations. Life insurance activities (technically, the fact of issuing or […]
US Tax Reform: Tax Cuts and Jobs Act Imposes New Limitations on Deductibility of Trade or Business Interest
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the “TCJA”), signed into law in December 2017, and applicable to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2017, contains several provisions that will have a significant impact on specific types of entities and investments. One of the most radical departures from current law involves new limitations on the deductibility […]
SFCR: Review of narrative reports, good practices and EIOPA recommendations
The Solvency II Directive increases the requirements for transparency vis-à-vis both the regulatory authorities and the stakeholders, including policyholders, financial analysts and investors. In this context, insurance undertakings and groups were, for the first time, required to publish a narrative report no later than 19 May 2017, known as the Solvency and Financial Condition Report […]
Ultimate Forward Rate (UFR): Why we are seeing a change to the rate curve
On 6 February 2018, EIOPA published its latest risk-free interest rate curve to be taken into account for the purposes of Solvency II calculations. Based on calculations for January 2018, the curve is slightly different from previously published curves. This is reflecting significant changes in the long-term expectations of interest rates in recent years which calculates […]
Action needed by foreign investment funds affected by new German Investment Tax Act
The new Investment Tax Act in Germany introduces new rules on investment taxation in the country. Coming into force on 1st Jan 2018, a widespread reform will apply to domestic and foreign investment funds with the transfer of transparent to non-transparent taxation status at fund level at a rate of 15% plus solidarity surcharge. Importantly, […]
Tax Registration Issues for German Real Estate Funds in Spain
German Immobilien-Sondervermögen are domestic open-ended real estate funds without legal personality which are managed by an investment management company on behalf of its investors. It is the investment management company that buys, sells and manages property held within the fund according to the stated investment policy. The investment management company is the civil owner acting […]
The Application of Tax Treaties on REITs
Real estate structures and tax treaty issues: questioning current thinking Real Estate Investment Trusts (“REITs”) give all investors the opportunity to invest in large-scale, diversified portfolios of income-producing real estate in the same way they typically invest in other asset classes – through the purchase and sale of liquid securities. Qualifying REITs are also tax […]
Assessing the impact of sustainable finance on insurance entities
This article is part of the series covering the impact of sustainable finance on the insurance sector. Read further:Part 2: How the insurance sector is meeting ESG challengesPart 3: Developing a toolkit for responsible investment decisions Amid a global pandemic and a rising threat of climate change, today’s society expects financial organisations to uphold strong […]
EBA discussion paper on the management and supervision of ESG risks
European sustainable finance regulations evolved considerably in 2020, and the European Banking Authority (EBA) is continuing this trend into 2021. It recently published a discussion paper assessing the potential inclusion of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) risks in the supervisory review and evaluation process (SREP) performed by national competent authorities (NCAs). What firms need to […]
Developing a toolkit for responsible investment decisions
This article is part of the series covering the impact of sustainable finance on the insurance sector. Read further:Part 1: Assessing the impact of sustainable finance on insurance entitiesPart 2: How the insurance sector is meeting ESG challenges Clarity of information provided to various stakeholders is a growing issue for financial organisations. Despite the efforts […]
Sustainable finance regulations signal a sea change for insurance sector
The European Green Deal aims to achieve climate neutrality by 2050 and create a modern, competitive and resource-efficient economy. To meet its objectives, the European Commission has begun to restructure the non-financial reporting requirements for companies. Although some of the requirements were partially implemented in 2021, this is only the beginning of a real sea […]
COP27: stepping up implementation and the role of finance
A lot of attention at COP27 was focused on the likelihood of keeping global warming to 1.5 °C, in line with the goals of the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement. The consensus was that we are in real danger of falling off track. Few nations revised their nationally determined contributions to reduce their carbon footprint compared […]
Results of the ECB 2022 thematic review on climate-related and environmental risks
The European Central Bank (ECB) has expressed a significant supervisory concern surrounding more than half of supervised banks in terms of the progress made on fulfilling the expectations specified in the Guide on climate-related and environmental risks. The ECB recently concluded its 2022 thematic review of the banking sector’s alignment with supervisory expectations. This review […]
IFRS series on sustainability-linked financing
As environmental, social and governance concerns are becoming more and more prevalent, sustainable finance is now under the spotlight. The financial sector has a key role to play in achieving the ESG transition. One of the levies developed by the financial industry is to propose new kinds of financing that promote ESG practices and projects […]
The FED announced a pilot climate scenario analysis exercise for early 2023
The Federal Reserve Board (FED) will commence its first bottom-up climate scenario analysis exercise at the beginning of 2023, as announced on 29 September. The exercise will be exploratory in nature and will not result in extra capital requirements. The list of designated participants consists of six of the largest U.S. banks, i.e., Bank of […]
Results of the ECB 2022 climate risk stress test
The first supervisory climate risk stress test (2022 CST) conducted by the European Central Bank (ECB) has concluded with official results and findings made public on 8 July 2022. The exercise has complemented the broader ECB’s agenda to assess the readiness of banks in Europe to manage climate-related and environmental risks. The 2022 CST was […]
How to address climate risk in the banking prudential framework
Climate change is now firmly in the focus of prudential regulators and supervisors across the globe. Against this background, the European Banking Authority (EBA) is mandated to assess whether a dedicated prudential treatment of exposures related to assets or activities associated substantially with environmental and social objectives would be justified. Based on its findings, the […]
Real estate share deals: survey and assessment from a tax perspective
The years between 1848 and 1918 are considered the relevant building period for the Gründerzeit-Zinshaus buildings in Vienna. In this period Viennese housing construction underwent a decisive development which shaped the city’s characteristic flair to this day: the Zinshaus buildings – so typical for Vienna – came into existence. Viennese Gründerzeit-Zinshaus buildings have not lost […]
France steps up sustainable transformation with mission-led business law
France’s innovative and incentivising Action Plan for Business Growth and Transformation (PACTE) law lays the legal foundations for corporate social responsibility. With more than 400 companies established as “sociétés à mission” – mission-led businesses – by the end of 2021, this new scheme is an undeniable success. The number of mission-led companies has doubled in […]
Eurofi financial summit addresses EU’s ecological and digital transition
As a setting for exchange between European Union (EU) economic and financial regulators and senior financial sector executives from the industry, one of the world’s largest financial services conferences, Eurofi, took place in Paris in February. Established in 2000, the Eurofi meetings occur bi-annually* alongside the Economic and Financial Affairs Council configuration (ECOFIN) meetings. The […]
Why ESG-linked features impact financial assets classification under IFRS?
In our last article on sustainability-linked financing, we highlighted the accounting issues related to these contracts that are currently being debated between stakeholders. The most critical issue is the classification of loans or bonds that reference the borrower or issuer’s environmental, social and governance (ESG) key performance indicators (KPIs) on the balance sheet of lenders […]
Banks need to step up efforts on climate and environmental risk disclosures
In March 2022, the European Central Bank (ECB) published its second snapshot of climate-related and environmental risk disclosure levels among significant institutions under its direct supervision. In line with the results of the first snapshot published in November 2020 – regarded as the baseline measurement – none of the institutions in scope for this second […]
Embarking on an ambitious common climate framework
As part of the European Green Deal, the European Union intends to encourage green investments and prioritise the revision of the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD). The European or Green Taxonomy, which sets out a precise classification of sustainable activities with the strategic objective of redirecting capital flows towards those activities from 2022, is a result […]
Sustainability and climate risk: what can banks expect?
The growing importance of sustainability issues and the role of credit institutions in financing transformation places climate and environmental risks at the core of regulatory and supervisory scrutiny today. For some years now, the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS), comprising central banks and national supervisory authorities, has been working to enhance sustainability and […]
The FSOC weighs in on climate risk
The Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) was established under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act as a result of the 2007-2008 US financial crisis. A first of its kind, the 15-member council is tasked primarily with identifying growing systemic risks to US financial stability and proposing coordinated regulatory responses to both preempt […]
ESG investing: Three risks to consider
The continued popularity of funds with an environmental, social and governance (ESG) focus has put global ESG assets on track to exceed $53tn by 2025, up from nearly $38tn at the end of 20201. As growth continues, expectations for effective compliance policies and controls in place are expected to become more rigorous as political and […]
ESG investing: From buzzword to mainstream
A growing interest in environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues is driving record inflows into the ESG-led investment sector. During 2020, sustainable funds available to European investors attracted net inflows of €233bn1, which saw assets under management hit the $1.1tn milestone, accounting for almost 10% of total European fund assets. A similar growth story in […]
Benchmark study of approaches to estimate probability of default in the context of climate risk
Recently, initiatives to tackle climate-related and environmental risks in the financial services industry have begun across the world. These initiatives followed the adoption of the United Nations Paris Agreement on climate change, the 2030 agenda for Sustainable Development and the European Green Deal. Stress testing and scenario analysis are a common framework proposed by different […]
EBA: draft technical standards on Pillar 3 disclosures of ESG risks
On 1 March 2021, the European Banking Authority (EBA) launched a public consultation on draft implementing technical standards (ITS) for Pillar 3 disclosures of environmental, social and governance (ESG) risks, under its capital requirements regulation (CRR) mandate. The consultation will end on 1 June 2021. Large banking institutions with securities traded on a regulated market […]
Germany reforms taxation of investment funds
The principle of tax transparency for investment funds will soon be replaced by taxation at fund level with partial exemption for investors. This will also apply to foreign funds with German income. The new rules have been integrated in the completely revised German Investment Tax Act (Investmentsteuergesetz). This will lead to a complete change in […]