Digital finance: governance & blockchain
Digital finance: governance & blockchain
Thu 29 Sep 2016
“Blockchain is a bit like gluten. Everyone is talking about it, but no one knows what it is,” said Tim Swanson, head of research at R3, the financial technology innovation firm that is leading a consortium partnership working on blockchain to develop industry-wide common practices and standards, architecture models and specific transaction systems for use in global financial markets.
Blockchain is part of the technology behind digital transactions such as bitcoin but can be used for a range of transactions. It can either be a private or public digital ledger of transactions, agreement and contracts. R3’s blockchain model is private and its governance is controlled by the consortium. Whereas with a public blockchain, where access is completely free, “code is law”.
The governance of blockchain raises significant questions of responsibility and regulation: who is responsible or liable in the absence of administrators? How can the legitimacy of activities be managed and ensured?
According to Kramer-Levin partner Hubert de Vauplanne: “In so far as both public and private chain operations cross frontiers, the methods of determining this system of proof can only be developed through an international agreement. In the absence of an agreement, there is the danger that legal control of the blockchain will be seized by a state power stronger than the rest. The precedent of the Internet and the legal control exercised by the US should serve as an example. This risk of loss of sovereignty is a real risk that cannot be ignored.”
It is crucial, therefore, to establish a new legal framework in order to fully realise blockchain’s benefits and recognise potential dangers, while nevertheless embracing all the areas in which it can be exploited. We must also take care not to hamper its potential by restricting it to traditional and ill-suited legislation.
In response to the concerns that have been raised, the European authorities are starting to take notice. Recently, the European Parliament endorsed the report delivered by Jakob von Weizsäcker, recommending that blockchain should be regulated proportionately and pragmatically. In France, there has been the Sapin 2 law on the use of blockchain for unlisted securities and for mini-bonds in the crowdfunding sector.
For CNRS and Harvard researcher Primavera de Filippi, “the benefits of a decentralised technology can only be fully exploited if we succeed in bringing it under a decentralised form of governance.” In this context, we may legitimately ask questions about the suitability of R3’s centralised governance for decentralised technology.
While R3’s proposals seem attractive in terms of governance, regulation and responsibility, we may ask whether such an approach will see the full potential of blockchain being exploited. Particularly as one of the main benefits of blockchain lies in the total disintermediation of transaction flows, whereas R3’s blockchain is aiming to develop into a new type of intermediary (a trusted third party) replacing stock markets, banks and brokers.
The structure of decentralised organisations also made it difficult to make decisions, particularly key choices that ensure they remain sustainable. In May 2015, bitcoin suffered its first major security breach. This was mainly because the bitcoin community had failed to take decisions to develop its protocols. How can we have confidence in a style of governance that is unable to make decisions required to ensure its own sustainability?
Further, decentralised collaborative applications could develop in an even more independent manner, eliminating not just the intermediaries but the administrators too. These independent decentralised organisations would be managed by blockchain-based software. We need to be very wary of an organisation managed solely by machines.
There is no doubt that blockchain could soon make it possible to change how transactions are conducted between financial players. But in order for blockchain to develop sustainably, we must study its ecosystem, working together with all the stakeholders. That will enable us to escape the vicious circle of decentralised or disruptive technologies which trigger increasingly severe regulation as authorities struggle to adapt, prompting the technology to become even more decentralised and disruptive in turn.
Want to get notified when new blog posts are published?Subscribe
Digital Banking: Lessons from Millennials
By 2025, The Wall Street Journal () estimated that Generation Y, also known as Millennials, would represent nearly half of the total active population in the world. The challenge for banks is to adapt their strategy to match Generation Y consumer habits and behaviours. Unlike previous generations, Millennials have the increased ability to choose between […]
Digital Finance : Meeting Ethics and Compliance Challenges in Financial Services
We recognise digitisation as an important topic for the financial services industry; for this reason, we have developed a content programme with the Economist Intelligence Unit that focuses on how Financial Services companies are adapting their risk and reporting procedures to the new digital environment. This unique programme of thought leadership examines the new challenges in […]
Could regulation play a role in transforming the FinTech business model?
One of the main differentiators FinTechs have is their current positioning within the financial services value chain ecosystem: they focus on customer experience while their operations execution and control activities are often outsourced to banking institutions. However, is this likely to remain given the increasing interest regulators are paying to these new industry players? While […]
Can BIS develop a cryptoasset regulatory framework without limiting the innovation process?
In summer 2022, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) published its second consultation paper on the prudential treatment of cryptoasset exposures. The guidelines outlined in the proposed document follow an initial discussion paper released in 2019 and a first consultative document issued in 2021. The complete text is set up as a new standard to […]
FinTech in Japan: a regulatory framework on the move to support a strong development
The field of money remittance transactions in Japan is expanding and is attracting many overseas companies looking to operate fund transfer and virtual currency exchange businesses. A regulatory framework for FinTech firms in Japan now presents major opportunities and challenges, not just in Japan, but for regulators around the world. To support progress and development […]
Interview with Nadia Filali, Head of Blockchain Programs at Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations: Is collaboration the key to developing a strong blockchain eco-system?
Nadia Filali is director of blockchain programmes and founder of LaBChain at the French public group Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations. Here Mazars partner Jean Latorzeff and senior managers Emilie Legroux and Christophe Bonnefoy talk to Nadia about the pioneering role Caisse des Dépôts is taking in the development of blockchain technology. Why and how […]
The banks’ business model – between function and transformation
The vast array of legal and supervisory requirements for determining a business model draws attention away from the inherent and indispensable need that a successful entrepreneur has for such a model. In the past, was an entrepreneur who had decided to run a bank ever asked about their business model? What is a business model? […]
Embracing a pattern of change: business model innovation across banking, insurance and asset management
In this third article of our thought leadership programme around the transformation of Financial Services, we are focusing on how new business models are emerging. “THIS IS A WORLD OF SIX-MONTH PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT CYCLES AND CONSTANT UPDATES, PRIMARILY OF SOFTWARE, WITH A HUGE PREMIUM ON SIMPLE USER INTERFACES AND TRUSTED SECURITY.” Christine Lagarde, Managing Director […]
The Six Key Themes of Internal Governance Harmonisation
As recent as 26 September 2017, the European Banking Authority (EBA) under the Directive 2013/36/EU published its revised guidelines on harmonising the internal governance arrangements of banks across the European Union. The EBA Guidelines will apply as of 30 June 2018 to competent authorities across the EU, as well as to institutions on an individual […]
An interview with Ian-Edward Stafrace of Atlas Insurance PCC : Embracing and enabling insurance disruption
As chief risk officer and executive committee member of Atlas Insurance PCC, Ian-Edward Stafrace is passionate about effective enterprise risk management and seeking opportunity from risk. Here Alan Craig and Enrico Federici of Mazars in Malta, talk to him about technological, regulatory and business model changes and how protected cells are enabling innovation. What do […]
Are ICOs the New Future of Start-ups?
The term “ICO” is a common buzzword in investment circles these days. While these “Initial Coin Offerings” are distant cousins of IPOs (in the sense that both share the objective of helping firms raise capital from various sources), their likely timing and means of achieving funds are quite different. An ICO is a form of […]
The Evolution of Banking
Over a decade ago looking at the state banking webpage for my home state of New Jersey, there were approximately 250 banks doing business in the state then. A similar check today would yield a list of less than 150 or so; a more than 40% decline. With banking regulation at an all-time high, the […]
TRIM: Is Winter Coming for Internal Models?
Measuring banking risks is a difficult exercise, but striking a balance between simplistic and overly complex measurement techniques is the key to accurate risk measurement. This was the substance of the European Central Bank’s (ECB) Chair of the Supervisory Board, Danièle Nouy, in a speech at the Austrian Chamber of Commerce in Vienna, on 2nd […]
Arkéa Banking Services : Innovation in Banking
Arkéa Banking Services began life in 2009 by offering white label banking services on behalf of third parties. CEO, Christophe Bitner tells Mazars why offering support to Fintechs is now an important next step. What’s the driving force behind the evolution of Arkéa Banking Services and what are the levers for growth? Christope Bitner: when the […]
Do Androids Dream of Stock Prices?
We look at the rise of ‘robostocks’ and algorithmic trading, and consider the repercussions on financial markets. An old investment adage mockingly states that “a failed trade becomes a long term investment”. The idea behind it is that if a security is bought and underperforms, investors tend to keep it until it eventually becomes profitable, […]
How companies in the financial services sector can measure their human rights footprint in four steps
The complexities of creating and implementing a due diligence framework to monitor and measure the impact financial services have on human rights can be overwhelming. The EU recommended UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights Reporting Framework (www.UNGPreporting.org) – co-authored by Mazars and Shift – , as well as the EU Non-Financial Reporting Directive […]
Bank of Ireland: Placing ethics at the heart of banking
Customers trust their banks with an increasing amount of data that paints a picture not just about their financial situation and preferences, but about their lifestyles. Bank of Ireland’s Garvan Callan, Director, Customer, Digital & Innovation talks to Liam McKenna Partner, Consulting Services – Mazars Ireland, about how ethics and good principles are essential in shaping […]
Innovation in payments with Compte Nickel
Compte Nickel is a current account service accessible to all. Operated by the Financial Supervisory Committee of electronic payments (EPF), this new payment account which has been launched recently in France can be opened in 5 minutes at a newsagent/tobacconist by anyone regardless of income requirement. Ryad BOULANOUAR, President of the the French Financial Supervisory […]
Harmonisation of internal model approaches, a new era for banks?
Basel 4 and Single Supervisory Mechanism act to reduce the excessive variability in the results of internal model approaches to credit risk. For more than ten years, Basel reform has encouraged the development and use of internal models designed to better place risk management at the heart of banks’ control arrangements. Basel II saw massive banking […]
Mobile money in Africa: promise and perils
As part of the content program on digital finance that Mazars has launched in partnership with the Economist Intelligence Unit, we are exploring in a new article on how mobile money is driving Africa’s cashless future. Over the last few years, Africa has become a global leader in mobile money with the rate of smartphone […]
What next for Africa’s mobile money sector?
Over the last decade, Africa has become a global leader in mobile money. The statistics for the use of smartphones as a payment mechanism are compelling with M-Pesa, in particular, by far the continent’s biggest mobile money triumph. Backed by UK-based Vodafone and launched in 2007 in Kenya by mobile network operator Safaricom, by 2015 […]
New constraints threaten the future of internal model approaches
At the same time as regulators as a whole express their support for the harmonisation, transparency and comparability of banking models at the European level, a new consultative document published by the Basel Committee on 24 March 2016 partly calls into question the use of internal model approaches when evaluating credit risk. The release of […]
Banks: Five Tactics to Survive Fintech Disruption
The revised Payment Services Directive (PSD2) that comes into force in January 2018 will essentially remove many of the barriers to new players looking to enter the payments market by providing access to customer data and accounts through an EEA wide common legislative platform. Already under pressure from regulatory change and increased competition PSD2 is […]
PSD2, FinTechs and Brexit: The Wider Implications
UK Banks are already gearing up for the introduction of the revised Payment Services Directive (PSD2) that comes into force in January 2018. By providing clear guidelines and regulations, the Directive essentially removes the barriers to new players and opens the doors to FinTechs bringing new products and services to the electronic payments market. While […]
Change in French regulatory landscape for electronic money issuers
The number of electronic money players in the European market has increased in recent years, from 4 in 2010 up to 48 in 2014*. Add to this the fact that numerous players beyond the banking world have also created their own electronic money institutions, including Leetchi, Google and Amazon and the sector is now seen […]
A sector undergoing transformation – changes in insurance companies’ business models
In the financial industry in general and the insurance sector in particular, traditional business models are increasingly coming under pressure – a trend that reflects technological, economic and social changes. At first glance, this represents a risk for insurance firms, since conventional business models such as life assurance are hardly profitable in this new environment. […]
FATCA and the Common Reporting Standard Applied by Life Insurers – a Few Practical Considerations
Within the insurance industry, automatic exchange of information under Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) and the Common Reporting Standard (CRS) is mainly relevant to life insurers, since non-life insurance and reinsurance activities generally do not give rise to classification and reporting obligations under these regulations. Life insurance activities (technically, the fact of issuing or […]
New pilot scheme opens pathway for blockchain technology
A new regulation introducing a pilot scheme based on blockchain technology is set to come into force on 23 March 2023. The new European regulation1 is an experiment to develop secondary markets for financial securities based on distributed ledger technology (DLT). Authorised participants in the scheme will be able to provide trading services and settlement-delivery […]
New measures by the European Central Bank aim to improve gender diversity
American entrepreneur, Malcolm Forbes, once described diversity as “the art of thinking independently together”. Today, diversity is beginning to emerge as a quintessential workforce norm and institutions have started to acknowledge the differences in their staff compositions that are deeply ingrained in the fabric of their organisational culture. With many challenges remaining, the independent think […]
The digital euro: the future of central banking in Europe?
Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) continue to receive increasing attention not only from the ECB but all over the world. So far, 10 countries  have already deployed CBDC programmes with another 15 countries  currently conducting pilot programmes. In total, 105 countries are considering using CBDC programmes, representing over 95% of global GDP and […]
Can markets in crypto-assets (MiCA) give banks a regulatory edge?
Crypto-asset markets have been on banks’ radar for some time. While interest and involvement have varied, regulatory developments have been a driving force. In September 2020, the European Union (EU) published a proposal for the regulation of Markets in Crypto-assets (MiCA), offering a uniform legal framework for crypto-assets in the EU. On 14 March 2022, […]
Fast close implications for real estate management companies
The market is seeing a growing trend for real estate management companies seeking to speed up the process of closing their accounts. This is largely due to the positioning of real estate funds in life insurance contracts requiring increasingly shorter valuation intervals. Furthermore, as the regulatory obligation to publish Net Asset Values (NAVs) within the […]
Positive behavioural and cultural change: the implementation of an accountability framework
As regulated entities execute their post-Brexit strategies and relocate their European Union (EU) operations from the UK to other EU states, a key issue to be addressed for those relocating to Ireland remain to be the impending legislative changes surrounding increased accountability standards for executives and non-executives. Not least, the breaking of the participation link, […]
The imperative of expanding the traditional MRM function
Financial institutions and non-bank financial technology companies (FinTechs) alike make extensive use of various machine learning models (MLOps) in core and non-core areas of their business. Banks, for example, rely on such models for a range of risk assessments, including predictive underwriting, credit risk management, suspicious and/or fraudulent activity management, fair lending compliance, derivative and […]
Can banks balance the opportunities and challenges of digitalisation?
The Covid-19 pandemic has amplified technology’s impact on the banking sector, helping to prove that technology now stands at the core of business sustainability for banks. In their constant search for convenience, digitally-savvy customers have pushed banks’ focus towards providing global business solutions more than ever. A new normal has emerged: an environment where banks’ […]
Deep hedging: application of deep learning to hedge financial derivatives
The recent breakthrough of data science and deep learning make a model independent approach for hedging possible. This hedging approach known as deep hedging is a robust data-driven method able to consider market frictions as well as trading constraints without using model-computed greeks. This article gives the main theoretical tools to understand the methodology and […]
Shaping the future of banking with 5G
Over the past decade, the financial services industry has been disrupted by the arrival of new players whose rise to prominence has pushed traditional banks – previously faced with little competition – to transform themselves. In this context, technology and innovation, particularly 5G, will allow the most skilful and agile banking organisations to take advantage […]
Reimagining the office in the work from home era
The working environment has always been an important factor for companies’ performance and their ability to attract talent. With the rise of remote work, this aspect has become critical: companies now have to ‘seduce’ staff to return to the office. Therefore, real estate services will play a crucial role in helping businesses upgrade working environments […]
Can regulatory systems come to terms with Facebook’s stablecoin?
Facebook’s ambition to create a transferable global digital coin between users on the social media giant’s messaging platforms WhatsApp and Messenger has been controversial from the outset. Perhaps not surprisingly, the backlash from regulators around the world was substantial from day one. The world’s leading economies were less than enthusiastic of the possibility of a […]
Why rethinking CSR is vital for real estate strategies
The pandemic has had a significant impact on our entire ecosystem. We have seen global CO2 emissions fall by a record 7% in 20201 benefitting the environment. Yet, at the same time, we have seen adverse consequences for the mental health of staff working remotely, with almost half (49%) of those working from home saying […]
Are more stringent gender diversity measures required?
Gender equality, while not systematically embedded in national laws, is clearly set in European law. The Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR) requires financial institutions to adopt a policy promoting diversity within their management bodies and, for the most significant ones, to set targets to reach gender-balanced boards. Despite these regulatory requirements, the conclusions of the European […]
GDPR and PSD2: what are the issues for FinTechs?
The FinTech model is reaching a new level of maturity. The first stage saw them disrupt the traditional banking business models using technology to impact the customer experience and relationship. The second wave offers FinTechs the opportunity to expand their service offering and develop their independence, provided that they understand their relationship with the regulatory […]
Rebuilding Credit Card Profitability post COVID-19
The current pandemic is having far reaching consequences across all aspects of society. Compared to other industries the impact on the credit card industry is relatively mild and from a customer perspective the value of on-demand liquidity is now clearer than ever. However, there will be significant impacts on industry profitability. Reduced international travel will […]
Re-engineering the banking sector
In recent years, disruption to the banking sector has seen an increasing number of partnerships between banks and FinTechs, as banks look to acquire the digital expertise now required for 21st century banking and FinTechs look to tap into the finance knowledge and consumer reach that traditional banks enjoy. More recently, this quest for technological […]
The Impact of Robotic Process Automation in Financial Services
Robotic process automation (RPA) is software that sits on a PC or workstation and is programmed to mimic the activities that a member of staff would perform. It will open applications, copy and paste data, and follow predefined rules. A robot will complete activities three to five times faster than a person. Customer satisfaction can […]
Should we be concerned by Facebook’s launch into cryptocurrencies?
Whether the launch of Facebook’s Libra will threaten global monetary and financial stability is a question that has been on all regulators’ and politicians’ minds since Facebook announced its cryptocurrency project on June 18, 2019. Donald Trump himself tweeted that, as a virtual currency, Libra “will have little standing or dependability” and that Facebook should […]
Future-proofing financial services: insight report for board directors
New technology, regulatory developments and societal changes, including those linked to strengthening stakeholder engagement, are substantially impacting financial services as well as the rest of the business community. For businesses to succeed in this fast-changing environment they must be led effectively by their boards and successful in seizing opportunities and managing the risks confronting them. […]
Implementation of post-crisis reforms and remaining challenges in 2019
At the last G20 summit in Buenos Aires, leaders called for the full implementation of all major international financial reforms intended to improve the financial system, in particular, those drawn up by the Financial Stability Board (FSB) and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS), the last being the review of market risk framework published […]
Brexit, Volcker 2.0 and the Bipartisan Banking Bill lead topics of 2019 Institute of International Bankers conference
On March 11 and 12, 2019, Mazars attended the 30th annual conference organized by the Institute of International Bankers (IIB). Agencies and regulators serving as speakers and panelists this year, included: •The Federal Reserve Board (FRB) •The Department of the Treasury •The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) •The Securities and Exchanges Commission (SEC) •The Office […]
Is one single payment standard the way forward for the banking sector?
The financial sector is bursting with disruptive Fintech start-ups at present who are shaking up the banking and insurance sector with innovations varying from online mortgage banks to online payment services. With innovation occurring at such a rapid pace, how are banks responding? To some extent, the arrival of the revised Payment Services Directive (PSD2) […]
Cryptoassets: Accounting for an emerging asset class
The sweeping growth and prolific collection of technologies that make up cryptoassets today have made it incredibly challenging for regulators worldwide to standardize and issue authoritative guidance. Professional accounting standard-setting bodies, like the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) are certainly no exception. What started out as just bitcoin […]
Crypto-Funds: Regulation? Yes please!
While 2018 has witnessed some turmoil in the crypto-currency markets, interest in this new asset class – and also in investment funds which allow easy access to crypto-currencies – remains high. On 26 June 2018 CBOE Global Markets filed an application with the US Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) seeking approval for a Bitcoin Exchange […]
Sizing Up Amazon Web Services
Fintech is prominent in today’s business lexicon, having migrated from the back office to a prominent position in both consumer and commercial finance. Its core functionality on mobile devices and wide application in artificial intelligence (AI) spans blockchain, smart contracts, banking, insurance, regulation and cybersecurity. And Amazon Web Services (AWS), a major cloud player, is […]
How Innovation is revolutionising the payments landscape
Financial Technology (“Fintech”) companies have kick-started a revolution in the payments landscape. Using state-of-the art technology, fintech companies are transforming how payments are transacted and processed. Banks and traditional payment providers are having to entirely rethink their approach to how they interact with innovations in order to stay on top of their game. Technological change […]